By Scott Stump – Senior Editor
We’re now only one step away from packing the Ritacco Center on Saturday to see who will be crowned as this season’s Shore Conference Tournament champion, but Thursday night’s semifinals look like they could be riveting theater in themselves.
Out of the last four teams standing, you have “old reliable” (perennial power Neptune), “new reliable,” (rising power Monsignor Donovan), “scorching hot” (Monmouth), and “trying to make history (Colts Neck).”
As for my picks, I picked a Neptune-Monsignor Donovan final before the tournament began (see: here. Or better yet, given the performance of the rest of my picks, just ignore it like the crazy uncle at a family party). I will stick with that selection for the final.
Here’s the tale of the tape:
(1) Neptune vs. (5) Monmouth, 6 p.m.
Coaching match-up: Neptune’s Ken O’Donnell is a veteran who has been to this point numerous times, so this is another day at the office for the head man at one of the state’s top programs. Monmouth coach Larry Cirignano is a coaching veteran overall, but this is his first season as head man for the Falcons, who are trying desperately to finally get over that hump and reach the SCT final. Will the atmosphere make a difference for a coach like Cirignano in relatively uncharted territory for the Falcons?
The seniors: Neptune’s Gary Foster, Brennan Fitzsimmons and Terry Hicks are the main seniors for the Scarlet Fliers. Foster is in the running for Player of the Year, while Fitzsimmons has been hobbled by an ankle injury recently but will be called upon for rebounding and defense. Hicks is a 1,000-point scorer for his career and transferred to Neptune from Monmouth Academy before this school year. As for Monmouth, the main seniors are Kyle Fagan, a jump-shooting forward; Richard Gilbert, a forward who will be looked upon to grab big rebounds and finish on the break; and Sean Bard, another role player who will be counted on for a key basket here and there as well as finishing in transition.
The stars: Foster leads the way for Neptune, as he is a relentless offensive rebounder and extremely difficult to slow down when facing the basket from the foul line. The main star for Monmouth is 6-foot-5 junior center Joe Willman, another relentless offensive rebounder who has the ability to step all the way out behind the 3-point line and knock down shots. Sophomore guard Neil Thompson is a rising star in his own right and this could be another big addition to his resume.
The X-factors: For Neptune, it could be Hicks. He has shown flashes of taking over games at times, and at other times has seemed invisible in big games. If he gets them 12-15 points, that could be a huge boost. I also think that junior guard Thomas Jones could be due for an explosion with his ability to shoot threes. Watch out for Lem Walker’s ability to score in bunches off the bench as well. As for Monmouth, what it gets out of junior guard Anthony Gibson should be a big determining factor, and if it can get double digits and great defense from junior Austin Whitehurst that would be huge as well.
The strategy
For Neptune:
- Push the pace and make Monmouth have to go deep into its bench or risk tiring its starters out. Neptune’s depth advantage is key, while Monmouth only uses about 2-3 players off the bench at the most.
- Get Willman in foul trouble. Willman sometimes gets caught swiping at the ball against penetrators or swinging to make a block. Get him to pick up two quick fouls like that, and it opens up the middle for Foster and Co. to go to work.
- Knock down shots from behind the arc. Neptune has had some horrendous shooting nights at times this season, so the Scarlet Fliers need to show the Falcons that this will not be one of those nights by hitting some threes early, especially if the Falcons go to a 3-2 zone.
- Attack the offensive glass. This is Neptune’s bread and butter. The Scarlet Fliers win because they create turnovers and get more shot attempts than opponents.
- Force Thompson to finish with his right hand. Thompson is explosive off the dribble and will cross over to his right side, but often he comes back left or uses a hesitation dribble to the left baseline. Neptune needs to force him right and see if he can consistently finish drives going in that direction.
- Get good position on Willman. He has a tendency to go over the back for offensive rebounds because he is so aggressive, so get good position on him and force him into backing off or blatantly fouling.
- Use Jabari Joyner and D.J. Gutridge to hound Thompson from beginning to end and force him to give the ball up when trying to intiate the offense.
- Gutridge also needs to get into the lane on penetration because if Willman has to rotate and help, that could either mean finishes for Foster, Hicks, Fitzsimmons and others or possibly some fouls on Willman.
- Break Monmouth’s will early in the game. Neptune has been here before many times, while this is a rare spot for Monmouth. Try and overwhelm them early on to get their crowd out of the game and dull the momentum that comes from having won 16 of 17 games.
For Monmouth:
- Force Neptune to settle for long jumpers and limit the Fliers to one shot. This is under the “much easier said than done” category, but Monmouth has the athletes to keep Neptune’s offensive rebounding to an acceptable level. Foster obviously is the main concern in this area.
- Keep Gutridge out of the lane. Gutridge rarely, if ever, pulls up for a jumper, so back way off of him in an effort to keep him in front of the defender. Once he gets in the paint, bad things happen for opponents.
- Take care of the ball. Neptune lives off of turnovers, so the less easy baskets you give the Fliers and the more you make them work to score in half-court sets, the better shape you will be in.
- Get it to Willman in the post. I think any Neptune defender will have a tough time stopping Willman deep on the block if he catches it in the post. He can either get Fitzsimmons or even Foster in foul trouble early if they can lob it in there for Willman to make plays.
- When you have an opening, take it. Thompson and Gibson are tremendous open-court players, so if they grab a long rebound and have the numbers going the other way, take it. Don’t worry about getting in a track meet with Neptune in that instance. Just push it down floor and go for an easy basket.
- Get Gibson going early. When he is able to get a few cheap buckets early on, it usually means a big night for the junior guard.
- Dare Thomas Jones to consistently put it on the floor and score. Take away the 3-pointer by Jones even if it means allowing him to dribble by a defender who is crowding him behind the arc.
- Don’t dribble too much. Monmouth’s guards have a tendency to overdribble in the backcourt, and if they do that against Neptune’s press rather than rapidly passing the ball around, it will allow them to get trapped and allow Neptune to start tying them up for jump balls or poking the ball away for steals.
- Withstand the storm. Neptune has the capability to go on 10-0 or 12-0 runs in the blink of an eye, so the Falcons can’t get down if that happens. Keep fighting because Neptune’s shooting tends to run hot and cold, so a hot streak for Monmouth could be right around the corner.
Game 2
(2) Monsignor Donovan vs. (3) Colts Neck, 7:45 p.m.
*The Griffins are trying to reach their second final in three seasons
and win their first SCT ever, while Colts Neck is already playing in
its first SCT semifinal in school history.
The coaches: Monsignor Donovan’s Mike Kearney used to be the most underrated coach in the Shore, but given his team’s success in recent seasons, I think you would be hard-pressed to say he is still under the radar. He is one of the top coaches in the conference and has brought this program to new heights, and he is experienced in these games, having led the Griffins to the SCT final two seasons ago. Colts Neck’s Lou Piccola, meanwhile, may be coaching in his first SCT semifinal, but he has over 400 career wins and coached in countless games against nationally-ranked powerhouses filled with major Division I-A players and future pros during his days at Xaverian in New York City. There is no atmosphere that could possibly faze him at this point.
The seniors: Colts Neck has seven of them, and that could make a huge difference. Steve Spinella and Mitchell Kates headline that crew, but they will be discussed in the category below. It really will be the play of fellow seniors Craig Perry, Adam Dombrowski, Anthony Salvati and Alex LeRoy that could really determine the outcome of the game. If they finish inside and knock down the open looks that will come from double teams of Kates and Spinella, the Cougars will be tough to beat. Monsignor Donovan also has some big-time seniors in Kyle Milana and Tom Carter, who will also be discussed below. Tim Price already showed with 17 points in the quarterfinals against Red Bank that he is capable of stepping up, while forward Scott Niewiadomski will be needed to grab some rebounds and defend. Jeff Onysko is another important role player, and guard Greg Colucci could be the one to draw the assignment of slowing down Kates.
The stars: Plenty of wattage here as well, as you have the Shore Conference’s leading scorer in Spinella, an athletic wing who can dump threes in people’s faces or drive hard to the baseline and throw down a two-handed dunk on somebody. He is at his best when he is attacking and not settling for jumpers, but he has the capability to completely take over games because he is also a good free throw shooter. Kates runs the show, and his play usually determines everything. When he is consistently breaking his man down off the dribble and whipping bounce passes to the block or scoring himself, that is when the Cougars are the toughest to stop. As for the Griffins, Milana is a four-year starter, a hard-nosed forward who takes it strong to the rim and knocks down shots. His only Achilles’ heel has been his foul shooting. When Carter is hitting from behind the 3-point line, he is one of the tougher assigments in the Shore because he is 6-foot-4 and can shoot over smaller opponents while also putting it on the floor and getting to the rim. He and Milana are both ferocious weakside rebounders on offense as well.
The X-factors: For Colts Neck, it’s the finishing ability of Dombrowski and LeRoy, as well as Perry being a third scorer. Those two forwards are often the recipients of passes down on the block from Kates or Spinella when the double teams come. If they can convert those lay-ups and grab some offensive rebounds to keep possessions alive, that’s huge for the Cougars. For Mon Don, the match-up of freshman point guard Sean Grennan and Kates, the new and the old stars, is one where Grennan has to hold his own. He doesn’t have to outplay Kates, but he can’t get eaten alive by him, which Kates has done to some this season. Grennan may not end up guarding Kates, but Kates will most likely be on him, and Kates is excellent at anticipating passing lanes, so any telegraphed pass by Grennan and Kates is going to get his hand on it and maybe go the other way.
The strategy:
For Colts Neck:
- Get Spinella the ball in space, where he can either make a move or pull up for a jumper, and if the Griffins send a double team at him, it will be too much ground for them to recover if Spinella finds the open man.
- Make Milana catch the ball far from the basket and have a defender cheating over to help if Milana puts it on the floor to drive. Milana doesn’t usually pull up from the wing to shoot unless he’s wide open, so just don’t let him catch it on the block or he will score, get fouled, or both.
- Get up in Carter’s face. Don’t let him get rolling from 3-point range or you’re done for. Make him have to keep putting it on the floor. He goes hard to the basket, so rotate and take a charge when he gets a full head of steam.
- Get Perry in a nice, 8- to 10-foot distance from the basket to sit and bury mid-range jumpers all day if the Griffins are going to double team Kates and Spinella.
- Don’t panic. Colts Neck has the offensive firepower to get back in the game if it gets down early, so it can’t get nervous despite being in this spot for the first time.
- Use Spinella to get Milana or Carter in foul trouble. The more Spinella can get into the lane, the better chance he has of getting fouled by one of those two.
- Dombrowski and LeRoy need to muscle Niewiadomski for offensive rebounds. Those two have good size and strength, so if they can carve out some position, they can get some points on the offensive glass.
- Limit the Griffins to one shot. Mon Don is not the best shooting team, but it is relentless in getting second chances. Seal off the defensive backboards and you’re in great shape.
- Occasionally run another defender at Grennan to trap him with Kates. Grennan loves to go left, so if Perry is in the area he should come off his man and come right at Grennan and force him to make a quick decision under duress.
For Monsignor Donovan
- Trap Kates repeatedly. Run another defender at him off of Perry
or Salvati and get the ball out of his hands, even if it’s 25 feet from the basket. Make Perry score 16-18
points to beat you. - Show a double team at Spinella and then rotate back quickly. Many times
when Spinella sees another defender coming, he gives the ball up. So
take a few steps toward him and retreat to see if he’ll give the ball
up. - Post up Milana at any chance. He could be the key to getting Spinella in foul trouble, although Spinella could be matched up with Carter. If he is, Milana needs to use his quickness against a bigger forward to spin into the lane or slice underneath for a lay-up.
- Get some kickouts to Carter. If Grennan can back Kates into the lane and kick it out to Carter behind the arc early on, that could get the Griffins’ offense jump-started.
- Beat Colts Neck’s big men down the floor. The Griffins need to try to beat the Cougars’ forwards down the floor in transition and try to tire them out.
- Force Spinella to settle for jumpers. He gets a lot of points by going to the foul line, so the more Mon Don forces him to pull the trigger from the wing and not launch into the lane, the less effective he is. Colts Neck often gets impatient on offense, and Mon Don needs to exploit that.
- Price needs to step up and have another solid game. He goes strong to the baseline and can get to the basket. If he is in double digits again, that’s a great sign for the Griffins.
- Take care of the ball. Kates alone has killed teams in crucial spots by tipping passes away and going the other way for lay-ups. Make Colts Neck pay for gambling on steals by going backdoor and getting lay-ups.
E-mail: [email protected]

















































Processing your request, Please wait....
